Skip to main content

The Otherisation of Bengalis in Present-day India

"What Bengal thinks today, the rest of India thinks tomorrow."

At one time, Bengal had shown the way to the rest of India. All kinds of progressive action, along with social reform originated here. 

Raja Rammohan Roy, Swami Vivekananda, Sri Ramkrishna, Vidyasagar, Aurobindo, Tagore were stalwarts who could teach the western world a thing or two about humanity, ethics and social change. Freedom was wrestled from the British by the Bengal tigers - Netaji, Khudiram, Master Da, Rash Behari, Bagha Jatin and Binoy, Badal, Dinesh.  Education and literature owed several path-breaking work to this community. Jagadish Bose, and Prafulla Chandra Ray spearheaded scientific thought in our country. 

Image for representative purpose only

But why am I raking the past and digging up history about Bengali forerunners all of a sudden? Ahh, typical Bengali sentimentality and nostalgia, right? Wrong.

Its because in today's Bharat, the Bengali is being pushed aside - both literally as well as figuratively. The stature of the Bengali bhadralok - already diminished by Punjabi-heavy pop culture, South-Indian dominant public services, heartland politics and Gujju businesses, is now at a historic low.

Am I being unnecessarily paranoid? Consider this:

  • Some publicity hungry "monk" from a religious organization gets away babbling some nonsense about Swamiji - the same great soul who could rouse the West into acknowledging the superiority of Indian culture and religion.
  • The dynamic Netaji is being touted as a "Hindu " leader; he who had secularism firmly running in his blood. His philosophy is being usurped to belittle Gandhi who was ideologically opposed to him. But Netaji and Gandhiji both respected each other as individuals, whatever their differences. Bose would have been the last person to insult the person - whom he had named Father of the Nation, owing to the latter's hold over people's hearts.
  • An actor-turned-politician from Western India likens all "fish -eating" Bengalis to Bangladeshi migrants. Food habits dictate character in these times, and as a strictly non vegetarian community, we are highly suspect.
  • A central university hounds an eminent economist incessantly for a minor property breach in Tagore's Shantinketan. The fact that he is a confirmed critic of the present central administration is just a tiny coincidence. 

You can always say we are sentimental. And anyway, the narrative is already established that nothing happens in Bengal, where we are only obsessed with films, football, music and food. And Calcutta or Kolkata has long being declared a dying city. The history of Cholbe na culture is the recurrent theme for denying investments and business deals.

And finally, our food habits. For us, religious festivals are excuses to eat more fish and meat, while the rest of India fasts. So we are different, right?

And different in today's lingo means dangerous. 

Comments

  1. A timely piece! Bose addressed Mahatma Gandhi as the Father of the nation. Bapu might owe its origin to Gujarati kin and disciples of Gandhi

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very well articulated each line speaks the sentiments . Wonderful piece of write up.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Does Mother Mary Really Come? You bet!

Prolific writer-activist-thinker Arundhati Roy's memoir, an ode to her mother's formidable personality, is cleverly titled, Mother Mary Comes to Me. Below the title is a picture of young Roy nonchalantly smoking a bidi. Irreverence, thy name is Arundhati Roy! At 372 pages, it is a tome, a sweeping saga that recollects both her mother's remarkable life, as well as her own. Is it a Memoir? Yes and no. Though the book title refers to their mother-daughter relationship, the book - at several junctures treats each one of them as independent and exclusive from one another. In fact, for a good part, her mother finds no mention at all, and the reader is engrossed reading about Roy's exploits and struggles through Architecture College, early attempts to find her vocation and calling, her dabbling with cinema, acting, scriptwriting; her romantic liaisons with the luscious JC, Sanjay, Pradeep et al. A life as extraordinary and unapologetic as Arundhati's mesmerizes in itself. ...

No Hopes for a Happy New Year

It's that time of the year again. When yearly round-ups are done diligently. Lists made, everyone sits down and assesses hits and misses. You tick off the "achieved goals" from your list. Make resolutions to fulfil the ones not yet surmounted. But I am doing something different. I am taking stock of my setbacks, my disappointments, the let-downs this year. I have absolutely zero expectations from the next year. Why? Because its useless to expect anything that I can't control. And since any chance of better days seems very unlikely, I am collecting the bits of my sanity to somehow trudge along the rest of my time on this planet. Why am I being such a kill-joy, you may ask? Well, not out of choice, certainly. What the world and my country, the air I breathe, the people I mix with, have become, all contribute to my rock-bottom expectations.  1. I am terrified, scared of what my country and its people have become. This wasn't the country I grew up in. It seems as if l...

Emotional toil of festival times

Festivals are happy times, right? Time for merriment, revelry, celebration, enjoying yourself... Wrong! Studies show festivals call for a steady spike in stress levels. Cortisol shoots up, starting with preparation for festivals, and remains high throughout, in the quest to do everything perfectly, "at least during the festival". Guess who bears the brunt of this? Yes, its the one who takes emotional labour for everyone she cares for - the woman of the house. She wants everything to be perfect, so works her ass off tidying and cleaning things. Then she wants her family to be fed well, so spends hours toiling away making delicacies in the kitchen. Rangoli to be painted - there she is with the brush. Festoons to be hung up - she's balancing herself on a stool. Furniture rearranged, flowers put up, puja room decorated? Yes, only one person who signs up for all this. Then there's the stress of the whole family at home, stepping on each other's toes. She has to appease...